Technology can release capacity. What will you do with it?

By Mark Vincent

Agricultural workers gather around a new threshing machine, considering what it may mean for their work and future.

The most useful technology conversation barely mentioned the technology

I recently spent time with a group of frontline employees at a manufacturing organisation, alongside one of its leaders. A major technology implementation sat behind the conversation, but we didn’t begin with the system, the programme or what people would need to do differently.

We began with their working lives.

What did a normal day really look like? What frustrated them? What parts of the job did they enjoy? What made it unnecessarily difficult to do good work? What would they value being able to do differently?

The answers weren’t grand. People wanted to complete the jobs they had started and spend more of their time building the products they were there to make. Instead, too much of that time was being consumed by things that got in the way, such as searching for missing items.

As the conversation developed, the energy in the room changed. People became more candid, laughed together about the realities of the work and began offering ideas. One long-serving employee reflected that, in roughly 25 years with the organisation, he hadn’t experienced many conversations like it.

The technology had almost disappeared from the discussion. That was precisely why we were finally having a useful conversation about it.

People were being treated as if their experience mattered. The technology could then be considered not simply as a way to make them faster, but as a way to reduce frustration, magnify their contribution and create new possibilities.

That experience left me with a question I think every leader investing in AI should consider and be ready to answer:

If the technology releases human capacity, what will that capacity be used for?

The familiar answer is “higher-value work”, but that phrase conceals more than it explains. It assumes the organisation knows what higher value means, that employees will experience it in the same way and that the time released won’t simply be swallowed by more activity.

The real opportunity is larger than productivity. AI could help people spend more of their lives contributing through work that draws on their strengths, gives them room to grow and leaves them with more energy for the people and responsibilities that matter beyond work. Realising that opportunity requires you to make four distinctions clearly: between friction and productive struggle, capacity and value, organisational ambition and personal growth, and reassurance and an honest account of the future.

1. Remove the friction, not the contribution

Searching for a missing component doesn’t become valuable because it requires effort. Neither does repeatedly entering the same information, reconciling systems that should already agree or chasing an answer that ought to be visible.

These activities consume capacity without necessarily developing the person doing them or improving the outcome for the customer. When technology can remove that friction, it should.

The mistake is to assume that every hour removed represents value. An hour saved is only capacity. Value depends on what happens next.

In the manufacturing conversation, the connection was tangible. Less time spent looking for missing items could mean more time completing products, resolving quality problems, helping a colleague or improving the way the work was organised. The benefit wasn’t an abstract productivity percentage. It was the possibility of doing the real job with fewer obstacles.

That distinction matters because efficiency measures tend to treat all time as if it were interchangeable. Human experience doesn’t work that way. Two tasks may take the same hour while contributing very differently to capability, pride, relationships and results.

Before automating a task, ask what the effort currently produces. If it creates only delay, duplication or frustration, removing it is an obvious opportunity. If it also develops judgement, reveals important context or creates ownership, the answer needs more thought.

2. Some struggle builds people. Some simply gets in their way.

AI can now produce answers that once required people to research, interpret, debate and create together. That speed can be valuable, but the finished output is only one result of the work.

The process of working through something that is hard may also develop judgement. It can expose assumptions, build shared understanding, strengthen relationships and help people internalise why a decision has been made. Skipping that part may get you to the end more quickly, but risks weakening the future capability and resilience of those involved.

Research into “productive failure” makes a related point in the context of learning. Manu Kapur’s work found that conditions producing the best short-term performance aren’t necessarily those that produce the strongest longer-term understanding and transfer. In some situations, attempting, exploring and even failing before receiving the answer can deepen learning. (Learning from Productive Failure)

That doesn’t mean struggle is inherently good or that people should be left to wrestle with badly designed work. It means we need to distinguish the effort through which someone learns from the effort that merely wears them down.

A useful test is:

If AI removes this effort, will people lose only the work, or will they also lose context, judgement, skill, relationships or ownership?

You may still decide to automate it. If you do, you then know which human capability needs to be developed or protected elsewhere rather than discovering later that it disappeared with the task.

3. Released capacity will be filled, whether you choose its purpose or not

Technology doesn’t direct the capacity it creates. Leadership does.

If you remove ten hours of work from someone’s week without being clear what should become possible, the space will rarely remain open. More meetings, messages, reporting and operational demand will move in. The organisation may become busier without becoming more valuable.

This is why “productivity” is too weak as the destination. Productivity is a relationship between inputs and outputs. It doesn’t tell you whether the output matters, whether the customer is better served or whether the organisation is becoming more capable.

You need to start with the value the organisation exists to create and consider it from three perspectives:

  • What should become better for customers?
  • How should employees be able to contribute and experience the work differently?
  • How will this support the organisation’s sustainable health and the returns expected by shareholders?

Those interests won’t always align perfectly, and pretending they do will not make the tension disappear. But unless leaders can explain how the technology contributes to a credible future across all three, employees will be left to interpret the programme from the most immediate signals around them.

For the manufacturing employees, the first possibility was straightforward: remove obstacles that prevented them from completing the products they had started. From there, a richer conversation becomes possible. Could the released time improve quality, develop others, solve recurring problems or help redesign the work itself?

Capacity is not the outcome. It is an opportunity to choose a better one.

4. Growth doesn’t mean the same future for everyone

People often come alive when they feel they are growing and contributing. What that means, however, is deeply personal.

For one person, growth may mean learning an unfamiliar skill or moving into a different role. For another, it may mean deepening their mastery, becoming more effective in work they already value or having greater confidence and autonomy. It may also mean more flexibility, less exhaustion or having more time and energy for family, friendship and life beyond work.

A leader can easily project their own definition of ambition onto everybody else. A promise that automation will free people for more complex, creative or strategic work may sound exciting to someone who wants constant novelty. To somebody who values competence, stability and the satisfaction of doing a familiar job well, it may sound like the removal of the very work in which they experience their value.

Self-determination theory offers a useful lens here. Richard Ryan and Edward Deci identify autonomy, competence and relatedness as important conditions for motivation, development and well-being. Their work also emphasises that people can express and satisfy those needs in different ways. (Self-Determination Theory and the Facilitation of Intrinsic Motivation, Social Development, and Well-Being)

The implication isn’t that you should diagnose people from a framework and design a perfect role around every preference. It is that you need to become curious before deciding what development should mean for someone else.

Ask people what work brings them alive, what drains their energy unnecessarily, what they value about their contribution and what kind of growth matters to them. The leader creates the conditions for discovery, but the employee must bring their own curiosity, motivation and willingness to experiment.

You cannot manufacture those qualities. You can create or destroy the stimulus from which they emerge.

5. A valued future still has to be an honest one

A human-centred approach to technology does not mean pretending every existing role can or should remain unchanged.

Sometimes technology will alter jobs significantly. Sometimes market conditions or the economics of the investment will mean fewer people are needed. If that is the genuine intention or a credible possibility, you need to open the conversation rather than hide behind reassuring language about empowerment and higher-value work.

People will already be reading the decisions, budgets and behaviour around them. Silence won’t prevent them reaching their own conclusions. It simply leaves them to do so without context and often with the worst credible explanation filling the gap.

We still use “Luddite” as shorthand for somebody irrationally opposed to technology, but the history is less convenient. The Luddites were skilled textile workers responding to machinery and wider changes affecting their trades. The related agricultural unrest of the Swing Riots involved rural labourers facing low wages, unemployment, poor harvests and threshing machines that reduced winter work. (The National Archives: Why did the Luddites protest?; The National Archives: What caused the Swing Riots?)

Today’s AI transformation is not the Industrial Revolution, but the warning remains useful. What appears to leaders as resistance to progress may feel to somebody else like a rational response to a future in which they can no longer see their value, dignity or agency.

An honest conversation cannot remove every difficult consequence. It can treat people like adults, explain what is known and uncertain, and help them begin exploring what a credible future might contain. When roles are affected, that should include practical support rather than a better communications campaign.

A valued place in the future has to be real enough for people to believe in, not simply attractive enough to present.

Start with the work people want to do well

The manufacturing conversation worked because we didn’t begin by trying to make people enthusiastic about technology. We began by taking their work and experience seriously.

They wanted to build products and complete the jobs they had started. They were frustrated by the obstacles that consumed their time and prevented them doing that well. Once those realities were visible, technology could become part of a meaningful discussion about what should change.

Before approving your next AI business case, ask:

  1. What work exists mainly because the current process or technology is inadequate?
  2. What effort develops judgement, capability, relationships or ownership and should not be removed without thought?
  3. If the technology releases capacity, what specific customer, employee or organisational value should it serve?
  4. What kind of growth matters to the people affected, and how will you discover it rather than assume it?
  5. What might people genuinely lose, and are you prepared to have that conversation honestly?

AI can help people produce more. That may be useful, but it is not the whole opportunity.

The larger opportunity is to remove what wastes human capacity and create more room for people to contribute, grow and experience their value, at work and beyond it. Technology can create that room. Leadership determines whether it is filled with something that matters.

What should leaders do with the capacity released by AI?

Decide what specific value the released capacity should create before it is absorbed by more meetings, reporting or operational demand. Consider what should become better for customers, how employees should be able to contribute differently and how the change supports the organisation’s sustainable health.

How can an organisation distinguish wasteful friction from productive struggle?

Ask what the effort produces as well as how long it takes. Work that creates only delay, duplication or frustration is a strong candidate for removal. Effort that develops judgement, reveals context, strengthens relationships or creates ownership may need to be retained or replaced deliberately rather than simply automated away.

Why is time saved by AI not automatically business value?

Time saved is capacity, not an outcome. It becomes valuable only when it leads to something that matters, such as better customer service, higher quality, stronger capability, improved employee experience or healthier organisational performance.

Does growth mean moving every employee into more complex work?

No. Growth is personal. It may mean learning a new skill or changing roles, but it can also mean deepening mastery, gaining autonomy, doing valued work with fewer obstacles or having more energy for life beyond work. Leaders need to explore what meaningful contribution and development look like for the people affected.

How should leaders discuss AI when roles may change or reduce?

Be honest about what is known, what remains uncertain and what is driving the investment. Positive language about empowerment or higher-value work should not disguise credible consequences. Where roles are affected, people need practical support to explore and move towards a believable future, not simply a more reassuring communications campaign.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Related content

The Most Expensive Conversations Your Organisation Isn’t Having

In most transformation programmes there are two conversations: the one that happens in the room and the one that happens afterwards. The gap between them, between what people say and what they actually think, is one of the most costly and least visible risks in large-scale change. Here’s what creates it, what it costs, and what leaders can do about it.

The danger of the finished answer

AI can produce a polished plan in minutes. But when delivery depends on people, the process can build ownership, shared understanding and resilience.

When busyness becomes avoidance

The operational work is real. So is the possibility that it is protecting leaders from something harder.

Are you building a faster horse?

AI can make the existing way of working faster. The bigger opportunity may be to make it unnecessary.

The technology is not the transformation

Your people may understand the system perfectly and still have no reason to care about the transformation it is meant to enable.

What makes people believe change will really happen?

People may still believe in your vision while quietly losing confidence that the organisation will achieve it.

Stay connected for practical insights